AMERISAFE competes on specialized knowledge, personalized service, and disciplined underwriting in niche markets. The company maintains high policyholder retention (93.1% renewal rate in 2025), operates through a decentralized network of ~1,400 independent agencies, and avoids concentration risk with no single agency exceeding 2% of voluntary premiums. Its A.M. Best rating ("A" Excellent) underscores financial strength in a commoditized industry.
Cyborg Score Rationale
AMERISAFE demonstrates strong operational fundamentals with disciplined underwriting, industry expertise, and market focus positioning. However, limited scale ($313.9M gross premiums in 2025), concentrated customer base (construction = 47.5% of premiums), and exposure to economic cycles in construction and other cyclical industries create headwinds. Solid governance and consistent profitability offset market structure constraints.
Top Insights
Construction represents nearly half of voluntary premiums (47.5%), creating significant revenue concentration risk to economic cycles
Extremely high policyholder retention (93.1% renewal rate) and low agency concentration (no single state >16.3% of total premiums) demonstrate strong customer stickiness and geographic diversification
2025 gross premiums of $313.9M represent disciplined, sustainable growth in specialty niche with 97.2% from voluntary business
Field-based safety professionals embedded in policyholder regions provide competitive differentiation hard to replicate at scale
(December 2025) 2025 gross premiums written totaled $313.9 million with strong 93.1% voluntary renewal rate
(December 2025) Net unpaid loss and loss adjustment expense reserves reached $507.5 million, supported by long history of favorable reserve development
(January 2026) Stock trading near $38/share, representing stable valuation for specialty insurer
Open the full interactive AMERISAFE, Inc. report
Strategic research, analyst-debate audio, full Cyborg Score breakdown across 11 dimensions, and saved-company audio playlists.